Among the Birds in Northern Shires — Edition Insights

(0 User reviews)   32
In Category - Birds
Dixon, Charles, 1858-1926, Whymper, Charles, 1853-1941 [Illustrator] Project Gutenberg 2014 Not confirmed
Birds -- Great Britain Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 68,144
Reading time 297 min
Text sections 12

Before opening Among the Birds in Northern Shires — Edition Insights, the edition data offers a quick orientation: 68,144 words, 4 hr 57 min estimated reading time, and 12 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 23.4 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Birds -- Great Britain,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Charles Dixon's 1900 ornithological survey of northern England and Scotland, based on two decades of personal observation. The book contrasts northern and southern avifauna, emphasizing latitude's effects on bird life, migration, and breeding habits, with detailed accounts of species in varied habitats.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.8/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

There are few things more interesting to the lover of bird-life than the comparison of ornithological phenomena as they are presented in various localities, separated, it may be, by but few degrees of latitude. Not only does this apply to the species themselves--for even in our own islands the geographical distribution of birds conforms a good deal to latitude,--but to their migrational movements, their resumption of voice, their seasons of reproduction, their gatherings and movements generally, and finally to not a few habits that appear to be confined within narrow territorial limits. We have already dealt with bird-life in its many aspects in southern haunts with a view to the comparison of avine phenomena with that of more northern localities; we now propose in the present volume to review the most salient ornithological characteristics of certain favoured northern shires, especially with the object of bringing them out in contrast by their comparative study. The ornithologist with a southern experience, studying bird-life in a northern county--say in Yorkshire, for example--will soon find that the avifauna of the two areas, although it possesses much in common, is in many respects different. Birds that he was wont to find common in southern haunts are rare here; others that were scarce in the south, and which he was apt to regard even as rarities, are quite common. Not a few species are met with that are seldom normally seen in southern haunts, and opportunities are afforded him of studying the nesting economy of species, the breeding areas of which are decidedly boreal. Then, again, the change of latitude involves a change of climate, especially in winter; slight, perhaps, it may be, comparatively speaking, but yet sufficient to influence the habits and movements of birds in quite a different way from those prevailing in the milder atmosphere of southern haunts. Birds that sing all the winter through in these southern shires are silent here at that season; others that are sedentary there are of migratory habits in the wilder and colder north--in obedience to those climatic influences that act upon the food supply, and so on. The farther north he goes the more acute will the contrast in avine phenomena become; and in species common to the two areas--to northern and southern counties respectively--he will find differences of from one to two months in the ornithological calendar. Lastly, he will meet with a multitude of interesting forms, both in summer and in winter, that are normally strangers to southern localities at one season or the other, or at both seasons.

We will commence our observations by an investigation of the bird-life along the upland streams--not in their lower and quieter reaches, but at some elevation up the hillsides where the waters hurry and tumble along over rocky beds and between more or less precipitous banks fringed with alders, mountain-ashes, bracken, and brambles. The southern counties can boast no such streams; and even in the wilder south-west of England the becks are wanting in that grandeur that characterizes most of these turbulent northern waters. For twenty years or more we lived surrounded by them and within ear of their noisy clamour; whilst the birds upon their banks were our constant companions summer and winter alike. To our mind the ideal upland stream is one of the most picturesque features in the Peak district. They may be grander and wilder farther north, but with experiences of them in the remote Highlands and the Hebrides in mind, for romantic charm and wealth of bird-life these Derbyshire and Yorkshire brooks, in our opinion, remain unequalled. Almost every valley in the Peak can boast a streamlet of some kind. Some of course are more imposing than others, drain larger areas of upland, and contain a much greater volume of water. Some plough their way across the open moorland, their bed in summer being dry or nearly so; whilst others purl down wooded valleys and along well-timbered bottoms, between the ridges of millstone grit that are such a prominent feature in this particular kind of country. In their higher and wilder reaches such rivers as the Dove, the Wye, and the Derwent--all beloved by the angler for trout and grayling--may be taken as very excellent examples of upland streams. The Rivelin, with its charming branches of Blackbrook and Wyming brook, and itself a tributary of the now polluted and ill-used Don, upon which grimy Sheffield is partly situated, were all favourite streams of ours rich in ornithological associations. So, too, was the Sheaf, with once picturesque Meersbrook, especially in its upper waters between the villages of Dore and Hathersage.

Charles Dixon opens Among the Birds in Northern Shires by positioning it as a popular introduction rather than an exhaustive treatise, drawing on twenty years of residence in the region. He stresses the marked differences between northern and southern avifauna, attributing them to latitude and climate—a theme he returns to throughout. The preface warns that southern-based bird lore can mislead a student of northern species, and the book aims to provide the necessary allowances. Dixon’s voice is that of an experienced field naturalist, confident in his local knowledge but careful to note the limits of his coverage.

A Northern Ornithologist’s Method

Dixon’s approach is systematic yet personal. He groups birds by habitat—upland streams, moorlands, forests, farms, sea cliffs—rather than by taxonomy. This structure reflects his belief that place shapes behavior. In the farm and garden chapter, for instance, he contrasts the secretive Hawfinch, which he calls “perhaps the most local of the Finches,” with the conspicuous Bullfinch, whose white rump makes it easy to spot. He notes that Bullfinches retire to shrubberies to breed, while Hawfinches appear in gardens only during fruit season. Such observations are grounded in repeated visits, not casual acquaintance.

The Bird-Catcher as a Counterpoint

A striking passage on bird-catchers reveals Dixon’s ethical stance. He describes their “sly insinuating methods” as worse than shooting, because nets take “birds he prizes and birds he cares nothing about, cocks and hens and young indiscriminately.” This is not mere sentiment; it reflects a conservationist’s concern for indiscriminate harm. Dixon notes that the bird-catcher ignores the brief close time, making him “the scourge of the fields and hedgerows.” The passage is one of the few where Dixon’s tone sharpens, and it underscores his preference for observation over collection.

Winter Flocks and Local Rarities

Dixon’s account of winter finches on northern farms is rich with specific detail. He describes flocks of Linnets, Twites, and Lesser Redpoles on weed-grown pastures, noting that each species usually flocks alone. The Lesser Redpole earns special praise: “to our mind, is the most charming of the three.” He remarks on its “utter trustfulness” and its “exquisite little cup-shaped nest,” and observes that it becomes rarer south of the Midlands. The Tree Sparrow, by contrast, is “very local and uncommon,” breeding in holes on farms but more frequent in wilder spots. These distinctions show Dixon’s eye for variation within a single family.

Latitude as a Lens

Throughout the excerpts, Dixon returns to the idea that latitude and climate produce “avine comparisons of the most intense interest.” He claims that northern shires are “much more interesting than the southern” for bird study, especially during breeding season and migration. This comparative framework is not merely rhetorical; it shapes his descriptions. When discussing the Crossbill, he notes it is only a winter visitor north of England. The Redpole, he says, is “decidedly a bird of the northern shires.” These statements are backed by his own travels to Lincolnshire, Yorkshire, Northumbria, and Scotland, lending authority to his regional focus.

Dixon’s book rewards a reader who pays attention to habitat and season. The chapters are best taken in order, as later ones build on earlier distinctions—for instance, the farm chapter references the moorland discussion of Twites. The preface’s warning about latitude should be kept in mind: what holds for southern birds may not apply here. Dixon’s tone is that of a knowledgeable guide, not a dry compiler, and his personal observations give the work a lived-in quality. A first-time reader will gain most by following his habitat-by-habitat journey, noting how each species fits its northern home.

I keep thinking about how Dixon’s patient years among the northern birds felt less like study and more like friendship. There’s a quiet tenderness in noticing where a thrush chooses to nest, season after season. I found that same gentle patience in Ornithological biography, Vol. 4 (of 5) — Themes and Context, as if both writers simply sat long enough for the birds to trust them. It lingers softly.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.

Reader reflection

Your personal reading reflection

Build a private reading journal entry for this title.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

Where are you in your reading?

2

What was your overall reaction to the book?

3

Would you encourage someone else to read it?

4

What was the reading difficulty like?

Related eBooks